ActiVote
← The 2026 Midterms
Texas · Court of Criminal Appeals Place 9 · 2026

Messinger Widens Lead Over Taylor in Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Place 9 Race

October 31, 2026
John Messinger
55.8%
John Messinger (R)
Holly Taylor
44.2%
Holly Taylor (D)
R+11.6%
400 likely midterm voters · MoE ±4.9%

How the race has moved (2 polls)

40%45%50%55%60%Oct 19Oct 3155.8%Messinger44.2%Taylor

ActiVote’s October 31, 2026 Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Place 9 poll finds that Republican John Messinger leads Democrat Holly Taylor by 11.6%. The poll was in the field between October 20 and October 31 (median field date of October 25). The poll was among 400 likely midterm voters and has an average expected error of 4.9%.

The headline result
55.8%
44.2%
John Messinger Holly Taylor

Compared with our October 19 poll, Messinger’s lead widened from 9.0% to 11.6%.

Messinger leads among rural and suburban voters, voters aged 50 and older, men, White voters, voters on middle and high incomes, and voters at every level of education, though only narrowly, 51% to 49%, among those without a graduate degree. He also narrowly leads among voters aged 30 to 49, 51% to 49%. Taylor leads among urban voters, voters under 30, women, Black and Latino voters and voters on low incomes. These group figures rest on subsamples for which the expected error is considerably larger than the 4.9% for the poll as a whole. Texas does not register voters by party, so we do not report a breakdown by party affiliation.

Political Spectrum

The following graph shows the support for Messinger and Taylor among left, moderate left, center, moderate right, and right voters. These groups are defined by splitting the Texas electorate in 5 equal sized groups of 20% each.

The crosstabs
Left
98%
Moderate Left
24%
76%
Center
63%
37%
Moderate Right
95%
Right
97%
John MessingerHolly Taylor

Taylor takes 98% of the left and Messinger 97% of the right, but Messinger holds the moderate right far more firmly, with 95% against Taylor’s 76% of the moderate left. Messinger also wins the center, by 63% to 37%.

Want to be included in our next poll? Check out the app!

Check out our polling page for our latest polls. For further details see our FAQs, polling methodology, AAPOR Transparency Initiative disclosures, and accuracy analysis.

The full crosstab table
ActiVote · Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Place 9 · October 31, 2026
ActiVote 400 LV Unweighted Weighted John Messinger Holly Taylor
Texas ±4.9% MoE 100% 100% 55.8% 44.2%
Political Spectrum Left 29% 20% 2% 98%
Moderate Left 25% 20% 24% 76%
Center 15% 20% 63% 37%
Moderate Right 18% 20% 95% 5%
Right 13% 20% 97% 3%
Region rural 31% 30% 67% 33%
suburban 28% 27% 58% 42%
urban 41% 42% 46% 54%
Age 18-29 23% 17% 34% 66%
30-49 43% 29% 51% 49%
50-64 21% 23% 60% 40%
65+ 12% 30% 69% 31%
Gender F 48% 53% 47% 53%
M 52% 47% 66% 34%
Ethnicity White 64% 60% 68% 32%
Black 8% 8% 27% 73%
Latino 24% 27% 44% 56%
Income Low 21% 21% 45% 55%
Middle 34% 26% 53% 47%
High 45% 53% 61% 39%
Education HS 20% 22% 51% 49%
College 72% 64% 51% 49%
Grad 7% 14% 83% 17%

Every poll in this race

Published MessingerTaylor Gap Sample MoE
October 31, 2026 55.8% 44.2% R+11.6% 400 ±4.9%
October 19, 2026 54.5% 45.5% R+9.0% 400 ±4.9%
Methodology. 400 likely midterm voters in Texas. Responses weighted by Demographics and Spectrum. Average expected error ±4.9%. See Why trust our polls? for the methodology, disclosures and accuracy record.